Opinions
2026.11.20 15:49 GMT+8

Ethnicity is not evidence of espionage

Updated 2026.11.20 15:49 GMT+8
First Voice

Editor's note: CGTN's First Voice provides instant commentary on breaking stories. The column clarifies emerging issues and better defines the news agenda, offering a Chinese perspective on the latest global events.

Recently guests, including geopolitical commentator Vincent Crouzet on FranceInfo's evening program Les Informés, referred to the entire overseas Chinese community as "spies." The Chinese Embassy in France has rightly rejected the allegation as groundless and harmful, urging French media and individuals to stop sensationalizing the so-called "Chinese spy" narrative and to repair the damage caused.

Crouzet's claim is not serious analysis; it is collective suspicion. It replaces evidence with prejudice and treats millions of people as guilty because of their origin. Espionage is a specific crime which requires credible evidence. It cannot be established by pointing to a person's Chinese heritage, ties to China, or membership in an overseas community. To label an entire population "spies" is not vigilance; it is prejudice, even racism, presented as a national-security concern.

Overseas Chinese in France are not a political bloc. They are students, workers, entrepreneurs, and residents leading ordinary lives. Reducing this community to one label erases individuality and denies people the right to be judged by their actions. Crouzet's logic is dangerous because it transforms ethnicity into presumed guilt. If an entire ethnic or national community is presumed guilty, the result is discrimination, fear, and exclusion.

Admittedly, states have legitimate security concerns, and journalists have a duty to examine them. But responsible reporting must distinguish between a targeted allegation supported by evidence and a broad accusation that stigmatizes a whole community. Without that distinction, security language becomes a cover for ethnic profiling.

Worse still, such rhetoric does not stay within a television studio. It can follow people into workplaces, schools, neighborhoods, and public life. Collective accusations impose an unfair burden. They require ordinary Chinese people to prove that they do not embody a hostile stereotype – an accusation made by others that they could never reasonably disprove. This is especially harmful in a diverse society, where trust among communities is essential to social cohesion.

Eiffel Tower in Paris, France. /Xinhua

As the Chinese Embassy noted, overseas Chinese in France have long complied with French law, integrated into local society, contributed to economic development, and helped deepen mutual understanding between China and France. These contributions should not be dismissed as irrelevant. To portray overseas Chinese as a security threat is to insult both their contributions and the society that benefits from them.

The "Chinese spy" narrative reflects an old habit of mind: treating difference as danger. When geopolitical competition intensifies, some Westerners find it convenient to turn any China-related elements into symbols of threat.

This mindset echoes earlier episodes in which immigrant and minority communities were collectively blamed for problems they did not create.

In France, the Dreyfus Affair showed how prejudice could turn a Jewish army officer into a symbol of national disloyalty: Alfred Dreyfus was convicted of treason in 1894 amid public assumptions that his Jewish identity made him untrustworthy, before evidence pointed to another officer and Dreyfus was ultimately vindicated in 1906.

During periods of geopolitical tension, ethnic minorities have often been made to carry the anxieties of the majority society. That history should be a warning, not a template.

France has long associated itself with its national motto of liberty, equality, and fraternity. Those principles matter most when applied to minor groups. Media organizations shape public perception not only through what they report, but through the framing they allow. A program that allows its guests to describe an entire overseas Chinese community as "spies" should ask whether it is informing the public or amplifying prejudice. Freedom of expression does not mean freedom from responsibility for the consequences of reckless generalizations.

Just as the embassy urged, French media and individuals must respect the dignity and reputation of overseas Chinese, stop speculative coverage, and take concrete steps to address the harm.  This is a demand for justice. This matters beyond the Chinese community. The danger of collective accusation is that it normalizes the idea that people can be judged by association rather than conduct.

Rejecting collective blame is not a denial of security concerns; it is a defense of fairness, evidence, and the shared dignity on which an open society depends.

(If you want to contribute and have specific expertise, please contact us at opinions@cgtn.com. Follow @thouse_opinions on X to discover the latest commentaries in the CGTN Opinion Section.)

Copyright © 

RELATED STORIES