US judge: No injunction for Beyonce over 'Feyonce' knockoffs

World
Europe

A federal judge rejected Beyonce's request for a permanent injunction to stop a Texas company catering to people engaged to be married from selling dozens of shirts, tank tops, hoodies and other items bearing the name "Feyonce."

The pop superstar complained in a lawsuit brought in April 2016 that Feyonce Inc's sale of knockoffs infringed her trademark rights and would confuse consumers.

But in a decision issued on Monday, US District Judge Alison Nathan in Manhattan said San Antonio-based Feyonce's choice to capitalize off the "exceedingly famous" Beyonce trademark did not mean confusion would follow.

"A rational jury might or might not conclude that the pun here is sufficient to dispel any confusion among the purchasing public," she wrote.

Lawyers for Beyonce did not immediately respond to requests for comment, nor did the people behind Feyonce, Andre Maurice and Leana Lopez, who represented themselves.

Nathan said that by replacing the "B" in Beyonce with an "F," the defendants created a mark that sounds like "fiance," their core customer, in a "play on words" that could dispel confusion.

One of the Feyonce items in dispute was a mug with the phrase "he put a ring on it," which Beyonce said was intended to recall the lyrics of her song "Single Ladies."

The judge found the dispute similar to a 1993 case where the federal appeals court in Chicago ruled against Nike Inc over apparel from Just Did It Enterprises that bore a "swoosh" logo and the word "Mike."

Source(s): Reuters